Current:Home > StocksCalifornia may limit how much company behind Arrowhead bottled water can draw from mountain springs-InfoLens
California may limit how much company behind Arrowhead bottled water can draw from mountain springs
View Date:2024-12-24 00:33:00
SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California officials may vote Tuesday to slash how much water the company that makes Arrowhead bottled water can pull from a watershed in the San Bernardino National Forest, the latest action in a yearslong dispute.
The State Water Resources Control Board will consider whether to issue a cease-and-desist order against BlueTriton, the company that produces the widely-known Arrowhead water.
For more than a century, the company has drawn water from certain points in the San Bernardino National Forest. The water board’s order wouldn’t bar BlueTriton entirely from taking water from the mountains but would restrict it.
The proposal comes after years of fighting between the bottling company and residents who want to protect the watershed and see it restored to its natural state.
The controversy began years ago after residents of nearby communities raised questions about the drying habitat in places that once had springs supporting wildlife including fish. The U.S. Forest Service acknowledged that a permit for pipes carrying the water had expired and issued a new permit for this pipeline to the company, which then was Nestle Waters North America.
State officials also investigated. The case went before an administrative hearing office for the State Water Resources Control Board. The office determined the company didn’t have the right to take water from several spots in the Strawberry Creek Watershed. In other spots further downstream, the office said more investigation would be needed for state officials to make such a claim.
BlueTriton collected 68 million gallons (257 million liters) of water in 2019 from the spring but only bottled about 10 million gallons (38 million liters), returning most of the rest to the watershed, the company said in an email. A portion of the water the company collected was also channeled to a Native American tribe under a longstanding agreement.
BlueTriton said in a statement that the company will comply with any final determination from the board.
“We have never taken more water than we believe we are legally entitled to, nor will we in the future,” the statement said.
The case has raised questions about water rights in California during a time when the state is grappling with how to manage the resource in the face of a drier future.
And it’s not the first challenge against bottled water companies, either from consumer advocates or groups fighting against plastic waste. The U.S. Interior Department said earlier this year it would phase out the sale of all plastic water bottles in national parks. Poland Springs, also owned by Nestle and now BlueTriton, has faced lawsuits claiming its water doesn’t come from a spring.
Amanda Frye, a resident of the nearby community of Redlands who investigated BlueTriton’s claims to water rights, said she couldn’t believe a private company was drawing water from a national forest and bottling it for sale.
“They turned a perennial stream into a dry creek bed,” she said. “I am hoping this can all be restored and it will help our watershed.”
Michael O’Heaney, executive director of the Story of Stuff project, said he doubts this will be the last of the fight. The group fights against over-consumption and is one of the parties to the hearing.
O’Heaney said that he and local residents will continue to pressure the state board to take action on the remaining points where the company is drawing water and the U.S. Forest Service to refrain from renewing a permit for the pipeline.
He also said he wants to see the company penalized for the years it took millions of gallons of water.
“It’s a really valuable natural resource they’re currently paying nothing for,” O’Heaney said.
Arrowhead got its name from a near-perfect arrowhead shape on the side of the San Bernardino Mountains, shaped by variations in geology and soil conditions. That’s also the inspiration for the name of the Arrowhead Springs Hotel, which began bottling water in its basement in 1906. At first, the water was only available for sale at the hotel. But the company started selling the water more widely in 1909, according to a 1999 report by Dames & Moore, a consultant to one of BlueTriton’s predecessors.
Now the hotel is operated by the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians. The order under consideration by the water board makes an exception for water diverted to the tribe.
veryGood! (74142)
Related
- Jordan Chiles Reveals She Still Has Bronze Medal in Emotional Update After 2024 Olympics Controversy
- How WWE's Gunther sees Roman Reigns' title defenses: 'Should be a very special occasion'
- 2 deaths, 28 hospitalizations linked to salmonella-tainted cantaloupes as recalls take effect
- Dead, wounded or AWOL: The voices of desperate Russian soldiers trying to get out of the Ukraine war
- Biden, Harris participate in Veterans Day ceremony | The Excerpt
- Black Women Face Disproportionate Risks From Largely Unregulated Toxic Substances in Beauty and Personal Care Products
- Playing in the Dirty (NFC) South means team can win the division with a losing record
- Georgia case over railroad’s use of eminent domain could have property law implications
- California researchers discover mysterious, gelatinous new sea slug
- Officials in Texas investigating the death of a horse killed and dumped on Thanksgiving
Ranking
- Olivia Munn Randomly Drug Tests John Mulaney After Mini-Intervention
- The body of an abducted anti-mining activist is found in western Mexico
- Why do they give? Donors speak about what moves them and how they plan end-of-year donations
- Turned down for a loan, business owners look to family and even crowdsourcing to get money to grow
- Early Week 11 fantasy football rankings: 30 risers and fallers
- College football bold predictions for Week 13: Florida State's season spoiled?
- Jordan’s top diplomat wants to align Europeans behind a call for a permanent cease-fire in Gaza
- 13 crew members missing after a cargo ship sinks off a Greek island in stormy seas
Recommendation
-
Quincy Jones' Cause of Death Revealed
-
US Army soldier killed in helicopter crash remembered as devoted family member, friend and leader
-
Criminals are using AI tools like ChatGPT to con shoppers. Here's how to spot scams.
-
Wheelchair users face frustrations in the air: I've had so many terrible experiences
-
Taylor Swift Politely Corrects Security’s Etiquette at Travis Kelce’s Chiefs Game
-
The best Super Mario Bros. games, including 'Wonder,' 'RPG,' definitively ranked
-
Alex Smith roasts Tom Brady's mediocrity comment: He played in 'biggest cupcake division'
-
How WWE's Gunther sees Roman Reigns' title defenses: 'Should be a very special occasion'